Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library & Museums
Scope and Content
The Samuel Brinkerhoff Collection was preserved and donated to the Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center by his widow, Mary Miller Brinkerhoff Hayes. Following Judge Brinkerhoff's death, Mary married Webb C. Hayes, son of President Rutherford B. Hayes. Additional information on Samuel Brinkerhoff can be found in the Mary Miller Hayes Collection, the Webb C. Hayes Collection, Pemiscott Land and Cooperage Collection, and the Frances Schwartz Collection.
Samuel Brinkerhoff, son of Abraham Brinkerhoff, was born in Phelps, New York in 1856. Following the death of his father in 1870, Brinkerhoff attended school in Hillsdale, Michigan. Three years later, he moved to Willoughby, Ohio where he worked as a clerk for Burr & Bates, a drug and grocery store. By 1876, Brinkerhoff had joined relatives in Fremont, Ohio where he taught school for several years before reading law with the firm of Bartlett & Finefrock. In 1880, he was elected justice of the peace for the city of Fremont, and the following year was admitted to the bar before the Supreme Court of Ohio. Two years later, Brinkerhoff became the Democratic candidate for mayor of Fremont. Although, he lost the election, Brinkerhoff succeeded in his bid for probate judge of Sandusky County, Ohio in 1896. Brinkerhoff became an early partner in a local farm implement company known as the Ohio Cultivator Co. His investments and his law practice provided Brinkerhoff with enough capital to gain partnership in the Jackson Knife and Shear Company, First National Bank of Fremont, Ohio, the Fremont Home Telephone Company, and eventually the Pemiscott Land and Cooperage Company of Caruthersville, Missouri. Brinkerhoff, along with John M. Sherman, owned some of the most valuable oil interests in northwest Ohio. His real estate interests included 10,000 acres of timberland in Missouri. Further, Judge Brinkerhoff held mining interests in Colorado and actively took part in the construction of several small railroads. Brinkerhoff married Mary B. Brush, daughter of one of the county's founding pioneer couples, Platt and Harriet Hulburd Brush. Following her death in 1891, he married Mary Otis Miller, the daughter of another prominent pioneer, Anson H. Miller. Civic minded, politically active, and an astute businessman, Brinkerhoff achieved personal financial success. His lucrative investments and partnerships with other local entrepreneurs created area jobs and provided Fremont, Ohio with a stable manufacturing base at the turn of the century. Brinkerhoff died in 1906 in Fremont, Ohio. Six years later, his widow, Mary Otis Miller Brinkerhoff, married Webb C. Hayes, son of President Rutherford B. Hayes. Mary Miller Hayes used much of the Brinkerhoff wealth to further her civic interests as well as those of Webb C. Hayes.
Scope and Content
The bulk of the Brinkerhoff collection consists of the business records, political documents and family and business correspondence generated by Brinkerhoff from 1889 to 1906. Additionally, the collection includes family legal documents, including trusts, deeds, and estate records for the period. However, its primary focus is Brinkerhoff's involvement in the early development of local oil, real estate, and manufacturing enterprises as well as his national interests, including railroading, mining, and timber.
10 ½ linear ft.
1 Samuel Brinkerhoff - Obituaries, Resolutions, Cemetery Marker
2 Samuel Brinkerhoff Estate
3 Samuel Brinkerhoff Estate
4 Samuel Brinkerhoff Estate Settlement
5 Samuel Brinkerhoff Estate Settlement
6 Henry R. Brinkerhoff Estate
7 Mary Brush Brinkerhoff Estate
8 Mary E. Brush Trust
9 Louise R. Brush - Personal Account 1894 - 1904
10 Platt Brush Estate & Brush Heirs Guardianship 1892
11 Brush - Brinkerhoff Book Inventory
12 Anson Miller Correspondence
13 Anson Miller Estate
14 Nancy B. Miller Estate
15 Buckland Estate
16 John R. Pease Will
17 E. S. Pope Estate
18 Rawson Will & Settlement 1889
19 L. Q. Rawson Deeds
20 Flavel S. White Estate
21 Flavel S. White Estate22 Flavel S. White Estate (Haynes & White Leases)
23 John A. Fuller Estate - Flavel S. White, Executor
24 Flavel S. White Real Estate (Nimo Deeds)
25 Harriet H. White Estate
26 C. M. Wilbur Estate
27 Caulkins Suit
28 Frank Heim Trusteeship
29 Mary A. Pierce Gunning Trust
30 VanNess (Bennett) Adoption
31 George F. Weaver Guardianship
32 Miscellaneous Deeds
33 Miscellaneous Real Estate
1 Real Estate Transactions (Brinkerhoff)
2 Real Estate Transactions (Brinkerhoff)
3 Brinkerhoff - Sandusky County Annual Taxes
4 Lucas County, Ohio Real Estate - Correspondence
5 Lucas County, Ohio Real Estate
6 Lucas County, Ohio Real Estate
7 St. Clair Street Property Toledo, Ohio
8 Harvard Terrace Toledo, Ohio Real Estate
9 Bronson Place Toledo, Ohio Real Estate
10 Brinkerhoff & Close Real Estate
11 Riverside, California Real Estate
12 Missouri Real Estate
13 Ball House Property
14 Croghan House Receipts
15 Dickinson (Martha J.) Contract
16 Canceled Land Contracts
17 Haynes & Brinkerhoff Rent Accounts
18 Brinkerhoff/Miller Real Estate Transactions
19 Miscellaneous Brinkerhoff/Miller Deeds
20 Miscellaneous Brinkerhoff/Miller Deeds
21 Brinkerhoff/Miller Fremont Title Abstracts
22 Miller Real Estate Transactions
23 Miller Real Estate Transactions
24 Miller Real Estate Transactions
25 Miller Real Estate Transactions
26 Miller Real Estate Transactions
27 Miller Real Estate Transactions
28 Miller Real Estate Transactions
29 Proctor & Brinkerhoff Accounts
30 Wolf & Brinkerhoff
31 Wolf & Brinkerhoff
32 Wolf & Brinkerhoff
1 Wolf & Brinkerhoff
2 Wolf & Brinkerhoff
3 Hines Transaction
4 Moun & Garanflo Land
5 Beaugrand Receipts
6 Investment Information Correspondence
7 Samuel Brinkerhoff Transactions
8 Inventories, Miscellaneous Financial
9 John M. Sherman Business Correspondence
10 American Car & Foundry Co.
11 American Carbon Co.
12 American Construction & Trading Co.
13 Bank of Fremont
14 S. Brinkerhoff & Co. - Oil & Western Mines
15 Buckeye Pipe Line Co. 1929
16 Buckeye Torpedo Co.
17 Commercial Realty Co. Stock
18 S. Doll Gas & Oil Co.
19 First National Bank of Fremont
20 Fremont Home Telephone Co.
21 Fremont Realty Co.
22 Fremont Yaryan Co.
23 Imperial Insurance Co. - London
24 Hercules Copper Co.
25 Jackson Knife & Shear Co.
26 Ohio Life Insurance & Trust Co.
27 Peoples Building, Loan, & Savings Association
28 Put-In-Bay and Southwestern Railway
29 St. Louis, Caruthersville, & Memphis Railway (includes Moark Land & Timber Co.)
30 St. Louis, Caruthersville, & Memphis Railway (includes Moark Land & Timber Co.)
31 Moark Land & Timber Co.
32 Omo Manufacturing Co.
33 Sherman & Brinkerhoff Oil Investments
1 Sherman & Brinkerhoff Sandusky County Oil & Land
2 Brinkerhoff/Hovis Transactions
3 Seneca Land Co.
4 Sprague Cutlery
5 Tidal Oil Co.
6 Tidal Oil Co.
7 Tidal Oil Co.
8 Titus, Townsend, & Titus Co.
9 Van Schaik Oil and Gas Agreement
10 Worst, Sherman, & Brinkerhoff
11 Ward Lumber Co. v S. Brinkerhoff
12 Wilson, Benson v Hopkins, Gilbert, Brinkerhoff 1899
13 Wilson, Benson v Hopkins, Gilbert, Brinkerhoff 1899
14 Wilson, Benson v Hopkins, Gilbert, Brinkerhoff 1899
15 Wilson, Benson v Hopkins, Gilbert, Brinkerhoff 1899
16 Wilson, Benson v Hopkins, Gilbert, Brinkerhoff 1899
17 Birchard Library
18 Buckland Guards
19 Checks and Receipts 1883 -1906
21 Family Correspondence
22 Political Correspondence
23 Miscellaneous Correspondence
24 Miscellaneous Memorandum Books
25 Miscellaneous Memo Pads
26 Miscellaneous Documents
Box 5 - Ledgers & Journals
1 Copy Book of Brinkerhoff Legal Cases 1881 - 1905
2 Notes & Loans Ledger 1881 - 1905
3 S. Brinkerhoff Journal 1905 - 1906
4 S. Brinkerhoff Estate Account Book 1906
5 S. Brinkerhoff Estate Ledger 1906
6 S. Brinkerhoff Estate Journal 1906
7 Mary O. Brinkerhoff Cash Book 1906 - 1916
8 Brush, Brinkerhoff Accounts Ledger 1890 - 1894
9 Trust Accounts 1887 - 1888
10 F. S. White Accounts Book 1887
11 Flavel S. White Estate Account Book 1889 - 1896
Box 6 - Ledgers & Journals
1 Brinkerhoff, Wilson, Buckland Oil Property (Brinkerhoff, Trustee) 1895 - 1899
2 Worst, Weirman, & Brinkerhoff #1 1898 - 1903
3 Worst, Weirman, & Brinkerhoff #3 1904 - 1905
4 Wolf & Brinkerhoff Unsold Lots 1906 - 1912
5 S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Meter Register 1893 - 1896
6 S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Record Book 1893
7 S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. 1893 - 1895
8 Notes & Loans Ledger 1879 - 887
9 New London Twp. (Huron County, Ohio) District #1 School Directors' Minutes 1841 - 1852
Shelf - Ledgers & Journals
S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Application Record
S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Ledger 1893 - 1894
S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Journal 1893 - 1896
S. Doll Gas & Oil Co. Stock Certificate Ledger
S. Brinkerhoff Journal 1896 - 1903
Worst, Weirman, & Brinkerhoff 1898 - 1905
Flavel S. White Account Ledger 1889 - 1896
Tollgate Account Ledger, Undated
Miscellaneous Ledger Sheets
Transferred to the Museum
Card case with Samuel Brinkerhoff's business cards
Coin purse with coins, and Mrs. Brinkerhoff's calling card
Steel engraving plate from Meek's Twentieth Century History of Sandusky County, Ohio and Representative
Steel engraving plate from Toledo Critic August 1897